Thanks guys. If I ever consider more fish, I think I'll skip on convicts and flower horns if they are that unafraid of other fish! I always heard that Chocolates we "supposed" to be a little more docile than Oscars, so I thought it would work. My Chocolate is now happy back with his/her old smaller "friends" he/she can control the lives of. (Two firemouths and a blue acara.)